Crazy Harry Potter theory reckons that Crookshanks is technically Harry's cat

And NOT Hermione's

More From Harry Potter stuff
20 articles
QUIZ: Are you more like Albus Potter or Scorpius...
PSA: You can now discover your patronus on...
Er, why is this sentence in Harry Potter...

If you wanna talk Harry Potter animals, we'd argue that Buckbeak, Fang, Norbert and Hedwig are all up there as the best. Scabbers would be too, but he kinda lost his right to that when he revealed himself to be Voldemort's number one fan. Typical.

But y'know who's a severly underrated animal of the wizarding world? Hermione's ginger cat Crookshanks, that's who, and now a crazy fan theory has arrived to make you question everything you ever thought you knew about him.

GIF
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Waaay back in Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban, Hermione nabs herself a squishy-faced furry ginger cat named Crookshanks and falls instantly in love with him like any true crazy cat lady would do.

Harry and Ron hate his guts to begin with, but once he helps Sirius prove his innocence and stops Harry from attempting to murder him, he wins 'em over slightly. Good work, Crookshanks.

According to this preeeetty wild fan theory however, Hermione wasn't Crookshanks' first owner. It claims that, before Hermione bought him from the Magical Menagerie, he actually belonged to the Potter family. Say whut?

More From Harry Potter stuff
20 articles
QUIZ: Are you more like Albus Potter or Scorpius...
PSA: You can now discover your patronus on...
Er, why is this sentence in Harry Potter...
Harry Potter and the Cursed Child Parts I & II to be published as a script book in July
GIF
Is a secret Harry Potter and the Cursed Child...
Is this why Professor Snape is such a dick to...

When Hermione first buys Crookshanks, the shopworker comments that he's been "there for ages; no one wanted him." Now hold that thought.

GIF

Harry finds a letter that his mum wrote to Sirius in the Deathly Hallows, where she mentions that Harry almost killed the cat on his toy broomstick. Harry even wonders while reading the letter what had happened to the cat after his parents died.

So um, is it possible that someone rescued it – Hagrid maybe? – and took it to the Magical Menagerie in Diagon Alley for another wizard family to adopt. WOAH.

There is a slight glitch in this one though because, as the Potters' best friend, Sirius definitely would have known their cat. And since he speaks about having to gain Crookshanks' trust and doesn't mention knowing him previously, that doesn't really make much sense. BUT HEY.

GIF

Let us know what you reckon to the latest bonkers Potter theory. We're over on Twitter @Sugarscape, waiting to talk fuzzy ginger cats.

NOW READ THIS LOT TOO

GIF
Related Article
The book everyone's talking about: Read a free extract from One by Sarah Crossan
GIF
Related Article
Life According To... Author Rainbow Rowell
Related Article

What do you think?

Harry Potter and the Cursed Child Parts I & II to be published as a script book in July
GIF
Film & TV
Share
Is a secret Harry Potter and the Cursed Child movie in the works?
Life has so much meaning again​
Film & TV
Share
Is this why Professor Snape is such a dick to Neville Longbottom?
This fan theory makes SO MUCH SENSE
Hermione and Viktor Krum - Harry Potter
GIF
Film & TV
Share
Viktor Krum From The Harry Potter Movies Really Doesn't Look Like This Anymore
​Galloping gargoyles indeed.​
Bookclub
Share
JK Rowling is releasing yet MORE Harry Potter books this September
CHRISTMAS HAS COME EARLY
GIF
Film & TV
Share
23 things you didn't know about Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets
"You'll pay for that one, Malfoy. EAT SLUGS."
Film & TV
Share
A Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them sequel is in the works
It's been CONFIRMED
Bookclub
Share
J.K. Rowling says we're 'done' with Harry Potter
It's officially over
You NEED to see what the guy who played young Severus Snape in Harry Potter looks like now
Film & TV
Share
You NEED to see what the guy who played young Severus Snape in Harry Potter looks like now
Oh we love a good throwback
Harry Potter
GIF
Film & TV
Share
Your favourite Harry Potter couple just had the cutest reunion
OKAY, maybe your second fave.
Harry Potter and the Cursed Child Parts I & II to be published as a script book in July
GIF
Film & TV
Share
Is Harry Potter and the Cursed Child being turned into a film? Oh YAAAS
Please please please please