Two American teen sweethearts and one dress! It's up to you to decide...

Who wore it best: Miley Cyrus or Ashley Tisdale?

It's time for another battle of the stars to find out who you think wears the same dress the best!

Both the stars were seen out and about in America in a casual patterned dress from Free People, an amazing US shop with really cool clothes. Check it out here! (If you are lucky enough to have friends or family in the US be sure to put some of their clothes on your Christmas list!)

Hannah Montana star Miley Cyrus wore her dress as a top, with jeans and dark brown boots

And High School Musical star Ashley Tisdale wore tan boots but kept her legs bare and wore it as a dress

So brown or tan boots? Legs bare or covered over? A dress or top? Tell us in the comments who you think wore it best?

If you like rating who wore it best there are lots more on Sugarscape, check them all out here!