i think cheryl's ace and it would be good to have apoint of view from a singer as thye no what's needed to be succesful in this carer

Omg why don't people like her. I don't love her or anything but I think she's really talented. I voted for 'Wicked! She's gonna be ace!' anyways.

what do u think?

ta be honest i fink they shud hav sum1 who nt in tha public eye! sum1 who mebe not even famous! they shud hav a talent show wer normal people frm normal backgrounds judge the contestants. people should b allowd ta apply ta b judges they shudnt give the positions to people who already have all the fame, glory and wealth! i think cheryl seems nice but she definatli wouldnt fill in for sharon she too fake i think. what all you guys think?

The way she comes across and maybe it's the media - she seems a bit horrible. She's definitely got the experience cos she's been thru the whole gentically modified popstar ting.

I thnk she will be a great mentor. She is the best singer in girls aloud and she knows all about being in a talent show coz she was in pop stars: the rivals so she knows what she wants in a popstar.

if she is having a hard time then why make more publicity for herself? surely if your husband/boyfriend whatever cheated on you, you wouldn't want everyone to know?! why is she making such a big deal out of it?

I dont think she will be a good judge !! I would rather watch Britains Got Talent ! :) x

She Should Replace Dani Not Sharon x

She will be a good mentor because shes been through it all so she knows what to do and everything =] x